Friday, June 28, 2013

White House Unsure What Files Edward Snowden Has

White House Unsure What Files Edward Snowden Has

1 Share
The Obama administration expressed heightened alarm today over fugitive leaker Edward Snowden's stash of secret spy files, as a new batch of highly classified papers spilled across the Internet, revealing how the U.S. government collected online data in bulk.
A top aide to President Obama conceded that the administration doesn't know yet all of what Snowden allegedly swiped while he was a National Security Agency contractor before he slipped to Hong Kong earlier this month and then to Moscow.
"Look, I don't know with certainty what Mr. Snowden has," Deputy National Security Advisor Ben Rhodes told reporters in Dakar, Senegal. "That's something that we're actively seeking to determine."
Snowden has already compromised "very classified programs" by leaking them to three newspapersand by taking files overseas, Rhodes said, acknowledging that the government still believes he's carrying the files on his person.
"So we have very strict protocols for how to handle classified information. It doesn't involve getting on a plane and going to Hong Kong and then getting on a plane and going to Russia," Rhodes said.
PHOTO: Edward Snowden, who worked as a contract employee at the National Security Agency, in Hong Kong, June 9, 2013.
PHOTO: Edward Snowden, who worked as a contract employee at the National Security Agency, in Hong Kong, June 9, 2013.
The Guardian/AP Photo
Edward Snowden, who worked as a contract employee at the National Security Agency, in Hong Kong, June 9, 2013.
The intelligence community is conducting both a damage assessment related to the leaks so far and a forensic audit of computers and systems that Snowden had access to, sources told ABC News. But the sources fear Snowden may have hidden his tracks well enough at NSA to make it impossible to determine everything he copied.
Snowden, who worked as an undercover computer specialist with the CIA before contracting with the NSA, is said to be in hiding in the "transit area" of a Moscow airport. Top U.S. officials have urged Russia to expel Snowden, who has been charged with espionage in the U.S., but Russia's President Vladimir Putin said earlier this week that Snowden is a "free person."
During his goodwill trip to Africa, President Obama said today that he had not personally appealed to Putin to send Snowden back to the U.S. to face justice, nor was he prepared to pull out all the stops to collar him.
"No, I am not going to be scrambling jets to get a 29-year-old hacker," Obama told reporters on Thursday morning, apparently referring to the chance Snowden could take a flight from Moscow to Havana, Cuba, which would travel over American airspace.
Did Obama Speak Too Soon on NSA File Harm?
While he is still concerned that Snowden could release more classified documents, Obama said he believed the real damage had already been done.
"I get why this is a fascinating issue," Obama said. "But in terms of U.S. interests, the damage was done with the first leaks."
But soon after the President spoke, The Guardian newspaper posted more U.S. intelligence files classified at the "SECRET" level and higher, as well as "NOFORN," meaning it was too sensitive to be distributed to foreign allies.
The NSA and Department of Justice documents detailed a decade of collection of email data mostly of foreigners but also U.S. persons, which top prosecutors determined was not constitutionally protected because it was strictly time, date, Internet Protocol addresses – unique to each individual computer -- and email addresses. The actual content of the messages was not collected by NSA under the program codenamed "Stellar Wind," according to The Guardian.
Read the whole story
 
· · · ·

Obama, On Edward Snowden, Won't 'Scramble Jets'

Quote of the day: OBAMA ON SNOWDEN: "I'm Not Going To Be Scrambling Jets To Get A 29-Year-Old [narcissistic treacherous punk - Mike Nova] Hacker".

Quote of the day: 
OBAMA ON SNOWDEN: "I'm Not Going To Be Scrambling Jets To Get A 29-Year-Old [narcissistic treacherous punk - Mike Nova] Hacker". 

Read more: http://www.businessinsider.com/obama-edward-snowden-scrambling-jets-hacker-2013-6#ixzz2XX2BY371


Mike Nova comments: I think that Snowden was motivated more by his need for personal "glory" than by his sense of social responsibility (possibly not unlike Assange). It is a subtype of a Herostratus crime. One of the differences from the classic version is that modern day herostrati prefer to live in diplomatic comfort rather than to face the music. 

Links: 

herostratus - GS

herostratus syndrome - GS

herostratus complex - GS

herostratus short story - GS

herostratus film - GS
________________________________________


Obama, On Edward Snowden, Won't 'Scramble Jets'

1 Share
Barack Obama Africa
REUTERS/Gary Cameron
President Barack Obama said on Thursday that he wouldn't be scrambling military jets to secure the capture of National Security Agency leak source Edward Snowden, saying he wouldn't participate in "wheeling and dealing" to get Snowden extradited back to the United States.
"I'm not going to be scrambling jets to get a 29-year-old hacker," Obama said of Snowden at a press conference Thursday in Senegal, Africa. Snowden actually turned 30 years old last week.
Obama also said that he has not spoken to China President Xi Jinping or Russian President Vladimir Putin about Snowden's extradition.
"I have not called President Xi personally or President Putin personally," Obama said. "And the reason is because, No. 1: I shouldn’t have to."
Obama has come under some criticism from Republicans in Congress in recent days for the failure to bring Snowden back to the U.S. Snowden departed from Hong Kong on Sunday and has now been in Russia for five days. His original departure from Hong Kong set off a mad scramble to find him, including a group of journalists who were fooled into boarding a flight without him.
Thus far, Putin has bluntly rejected the White House's requests for extradition, saying it did not have reason to extradite Snowden because he had not committed any crimes in Russia. On Tuesday, the White House pushed Russia's government to "expel Mr. Snowden without delay."
Snowden, a former NSA contractor at Booz Allen Hamilton, was charged on June 14 with three felonies after leaking a trove of secrets about the NSA's surveillance programs. Each of the felonies carries a possible 10-year prison sentence.
Read the whole story

· ·

Federation Council Invites Snowden to Investigate Spying Claims | News

1 Share
Russia's parliament has extended an

Federation Council Invites Snowden to Investigate Spying Claims | News

Federation Council Invites Snowden to Investigate Spying Claims | News

1 Share
Russia's parliament has extended an invitation to fugitive ex-CIA employee Edward Snowden to help investigate whether U.S. Internet firms provided information about Russian citizens to the U.S. government.
Snowden, a former contractor for the National Security Agency, is wanted by the U.S. for disclosing a top-secret surveillance program that allegedly targeted millions of Americans. He is reportedly in Moscow.
"We invite Edward Snowden to work with us and hope that as soon as he settles his legal status, he will collaborate with our working group and provide us with proof of U.S. intelligences agencies' access to the servers of Internet firms," Senator Ruslan Gattarov said Thursday, a day after Russia's upper house of parliament, the Federation Council, decided to set up a special working group to investigate Snowden's claims.
Gattarov, appointed to lead the group, told RIA-Novosti that it would incorporate legislators, diplomats, prosecutors and communications officials. Preliminary results of the investigation should be made public in October.
Meanwhile, a member of President Vladimir Putin's Human Rights Council, Kirill Kabanov, has said he asked his colleagues to consider asking the government to grant political asylum to Snowden. The council's chairman, Mikhail Fedotov, said the request would be considered and put to a vote.
President Barack Obama said Thursday that the U.S. would not engage in "wheeling and dealing" to win Snowden's extradition.
Senior U.S. lawmakers, however, seem more inclined to force the issue.
Senator Lindsey Graham, a Republican from South Carolina, said that he is preparing a package of measures to pressure Russia to assist the U.S. in securing the detention of Snowden.
"We are exploring what are the leverage points. I'm trying to put together a package to let the Russians know how serious we are," Graham told The Daily Beast Thursday. "We have to respond, this is a defining moment in the relationship."
Graham declined to elaborate on what measures he and his colleagues might pursue, though he accused Russia of ignoring the rule of law both domestically and abroad, adding that Putin is "trying to recreate the old Soviet Union attitude and image."
Snowden himself apparently remains in limbo at Moscow's Sheremetyevo Airport, where Putin said he had been waiting in the transit area since his arrival on Sunday. He had been expected to fly to Havana on Monday en route to Ecuador, where he has asked for asylum, but witnesses said the flight left without any sign of him on board.
An immigration official said Snowden had not applied for a visa to enter Russia and that he could remain in the transit area "as long as he wants" without applying for a transit visa.
In the Ecuadorean capital of Quito, the government said it had not processed Snowden's asylum request because he had not reached any of its diplomatic premises.
Bristling at suggestions that Quito was weighing the pros and cons of Snowden's case in terms of its own interests, officials also said Ecuador would waive its preferential trade rights under a soon-to-expire treaty with the U.S.
Material from The Moscow Times is included in this report. 
Related articles:
Read the whole story
 
· ·

Retired U.S. General Probed Over Stuxnet Leak

What Edward Snowden Can Expect Under Russian Law

What Edward Snowden Can Expect Under Russian Law

1 Share
Edward Snowden
Former NSA employee Edward Snowden, who remains in the transit area at Sheremetyevo Airport, could remain there indefinitely, even as the US attempts to have him extradited for the disclosure of information about government surveillance of electronic communications. This matter is regulated in Russia under Art. 31 of the Law on Entry and Exit. According to attorney Vladislav Kocherin from the Legis Group, in order to remain in Russia lawfully for more than 24 hours, Snowden must obtain a transit visa, which can be issued to him for a period of no more than 10 days. Such a visa is for one-time use only and can be extended only if there are specific reasons; for example, in the event that it is impossible to depart Russia due to extreme circumstances. In Kocherin’s opinion, in revoking Snowden’s passport, the US has created such circumstances and Snowden’s visa may be extended until he disappears.
A representative of the Foreign Ministry did not reply to Vedomosti’s question as to whether Snowden was issued a transit visa.
The US may initiate an official procedure to extradite Snowden, based on a 1999 Russian-American agreement on mutual legal aid in criminal cases; there is no extradition agreement between Russia and the US. However, the 1999 agreement, according to Kocherin, is very unspecific and does not bind Russia to any actions regarding Snowden’s extradition. Representatives of the Prosecutor General’s Office (where the request must be sent) and the Interior Ministry and Federal Security Service (which must fulfill the requests of the Prosecutor General’s Office) did not answer Vedomosti’s question about whether such a request had been received from the US. If there is the political will, Snowden must be extradited within two weeks, but if he manages to submit a complaint to the European Court of Human Rights, the process may take years, says attorney Andrei Andrusenko.
In their statements this week, US Secretary of State John Kerry and State Department Spokesman Patrick Ventrell did not say whether a formal request for Snowden’s extradition had been sent to Russia, but they noted that the US had turned over several important Russian criminals to Russia in recent years and can count on reciprocity.
But only some small fry were given to Russian law-enforcement agencies, and when requests were made for criminals of serious interest to the Russian Interior Ministry, the Americans basically sent back form letters or suggestions to find information about them on the Internet, said an Interior Ministry official. Thus, the atmosphere on this issue cannot be said to be favorable.
Political bargaining with the US over the fate of Snowden would be awkward and is unlikely be made: if Moscow turned Snowden over to Washington, it would be humiliated before the whole world, half of whom consider him a hero, political analyst Fyodor Lukyanov believes. Therefore, the period of his stay at Sheremetyevo will last as long as the search for a safe country to which he could fly, but there are only a few such countries which don’t fear a confrontation with the US, and the search could drag on for some time.
Read the whole story
 
· ·

Edward Snowden: in defence of whistleblowers | Editorial | Comment is free

1 Share
Link to video: NSA whistleblower Edward Snowden: 'I don't want to live in a society that does these sort of things'
No government or bureaucracy loves a whistleblower. Those who leak official information will often be denounced, prosecuted or smeared. The more serious the leak, the fiercer the pursuit and the greater the punishment. Edward Snowden knew as much before contacting this newspaper to reveal some of the things that troubled him about the work, scope and oversight of the US and British intelligence agencies. He is unlikely to be surprised at the clamour to have him locked up for life, or to have seen himself denounced as a traitor.
It was also quite predictable that Snowden would be charged with criminal offences, even if there is something shocking in the use of the 1917 Espionage Act – a measure intended to prevent anti-war speech in the first world war by treating it as sedition. On the available evidence Snowden's almost certain motive for speaking out was far removed from anything resembling espionage, sedition or anti-Americanism. His attempts to stay beyond the clutches of US law may involve travel to countries with a poor record on freedom of expression. But his choice of refuge does not, of itself, make him a traitor. As Buzzfeed's Ben Smith has written ("You don't have to like Edward Snowden"): "Snowden's personal story is interesting only because the new details he revealed are so much more interesting. We know substantially more about domestic surveillance than we did, thanks largely to stories and documents printed by The Guardian. They would have been just as revelatory without Snowden's name on them."
America is blessed with a first amendment, which prevents prior restraint and affords a considerable measure of protection to free speech. But the Obama administration has equally shown a dismaying aggression in not only criminalising leaking and whistleblowing, but also recently placing reporters under surveillance – tracking them and pulling their phone and email logs in order to monitor their sources for stories that were patently of public importance.
There is a link to the material Snowden has leaked, and to his stated motive for doing so. In a world of total monitoring – where intelligence agencies aspire to collect and store every single email, text message and phone call – serious investigative reporting becomes difficult, if not impossible. Normal interchanges between sources and journalists cannot take place in such a world. Officials who were once willing to talk are already chilled. In future they would be silenced. Thanks to Edward Snowden we are beginning to glimpse what another NSA whistleblower, Thomas Drake, has described as "a vast, systemic institutionalized, industrial-scale Leviathan surveillance state that has clearly gone far beyond the original mandate to deal with terrorism".
President Obama has welcomed the debate about the uses, limits and oversight of surveillance – and there is now a vigorous discussion emerging in America and Europe, if not so much in a too-complacent Britain. But a debate is only possible because of the facts which have been put into the public domain, not by government but by a whistleblower and a still freeish press. This much was acknowledged yesterday by the German justice minister, Sabine Leutheusser-Schnarrenberger, who yesterday wrote to our own home secretary in forthright terms: "In today's world, the new media form the cornerstone of a free exchange of views and information."
Max Frankel, the 83-year-old former New York Times executive editor, wrote this week in his old newspaper: "As those of us who had to defend the 1971 publication of the secret Pentagon Papers about the Vietnam War have been arguing ever since, there can be no mature discussion of national security policies without the disclosure – authorized or not – of the government's hoard of secrets." He is right. Daniel Ellsberg, the leaker 40 years ago, was smeared and denounced at the time. His trial in 1973 collapsed in 1973. History will be kinder to him – and, quite possibly, to Snowden.
• The headline on this article was amended on 26 June 2013 to give a more accurate representation of the article's substance