Saturday, August 27, 2016

Why We Need Kremlinology Again - The American Interest


Fire Kills at Least 16 in Moscow Printing Facility


Why We Need Kremlinology Again

Anders Åslund, The American Interest
In this week’s article for the American Interest, Anders Åslund, senior fellow at the Atlantic Council, argues that a return to the “Kremlinology” approach to analyzing Russian politics may prove useful at a time when the political landscape is becoming increasingly opaque. Åslund defines Kremlinology as “the formalized study of hard facts in a closed society, observing appointments, organization, decrees, and formal speeches.” This approach, now seen as a relic of Cold War era Russian Studies, could help Western policymakers and experts interpret the unexpected and often mysterious appointments and dismissals that have taken place over the past few years in the upper echelons of the Russian power structure. The author points out that recent photographs of top-level Kremlin meetings suggest a protocol resembling the strict fashion in which senior Soviet officials would arrange themselves by rank during governmental engagements, and that this protocol could in fact tell us more about the status of Putin’s ruling party than Kremlin propaganda would have us know. Åslund suggests that through the lens of Kremlinology, Russia’s Security Council could effectively oust Putin, and that the significance of this institution is often ignored by Western analysts. In an atmosphere of perpetual disinformation, could a return to Kremlinology be the key to understanding who governs whom in Putin’s Russia?

Морская пехота КФл в рамках внезапной проверки провела учения по уничтожению НВФ

1 Share
Также были отработаны вопросы организации взаимодействия подразделений морской пехоты КФл с территориальными органами МВД и ФСБ России на маршрутах выдвижения при совершении марша и в ходе операции по уничтожению условных НВФ.

Полевые пункты управления 58 и 49 армий ЮВО развернуты на полигонах в Ставрополье и Краснодарском крае

1 Share
В целях обеспечения боевого управления с оперативным составом объединений проведены тренировки по обмену информацией на средствах АСУ, установлена радиорелейная связь и закрытая видеоконференцсвязь с командными пунктами подчиненных соединений и воинских частей.

Дежавю. Детское порно и дело Буковского - 26 августа, 2016

1 Share
Детское порно – идеальный инструмент компрометации. Кому понадобилось опорочить Владимира Буковского? В программе Александра Подрабинека «Дежавю» адвокат Вадим Клювгант, журналист Антон Носик, юрист Павел Строилов.



Download audio: http://audio.rferl.org/RU/2016/08/26/20160826-153000-RU081-program.mp3

Виктория и Тимур Пономарёвы просят защиты от оборотней в погонах, фабрикующих уголовные дела!

1 Share
29 августа и 02 сентября


Путин уволил двух генералов СКР - РБК

1 Share

РБК

Путин уволил двух генералов СКР
РБК
Президент России Владимир Путин уволил двух генералов СКР. Это замглавы главного управления процессуального контроля в сфере противодействия коррупции Дмитрий Шершаков и первый замглавы главного управления обеспечения деятельности СК Виталий Фролов. Из СКР ...
Путин освободил от должности двух генерал-майоров Следственного комитетаТАСС
Владимир Путин провел перестановки в силовых структурахКоммерсантъ 

Путин уволил двух генералов Следственного комитетаLenta.ru
Вести.Ru
 -Взгляд-ИА REGNUM-NEWSru.com
Все похожие статьи: 126 »

Порошенко и Макей обсудили перспективы экономического сотрудничества между Украиной и Белоруссией - Росбалт.RU

1 Share

Росбалт.RU

Порошенко и Макей обсудили перспективы экономического сотрудничества между Украиной и Белоруссией
Росбалт.RU
Президент Украины Петр Порошенко и министр иностранных дел Белоруссии Владимир Макей на встрече в Киеве обсудили актуальные вопросы двусторонних отношений между двумя странами. Об этом сообщает пресс-служба украинского президента. «Собеседники подчеркнули ...
Порошенко обсудил с главой МИД Белоруссии сотрудничество в сфере энергетикиРИА Новости
Минск поблагодарил Порошенко за помощь в восстановлении диалога Белоруссии с ЕСВзгляд
Сотрудничество и обустройство границы: Порошенко провел переговоры с главой МИД БеларусиОбозреватель
TUT.BY (пресс-релиз) -MIGnews.com.ua -ЮПИмонитор -NewsONE
Все похожие статьи: 51 »
Next Page of Stories
Loading...
Page 2

США знают о стремлении России к серьезному военному сотрудничеству по Сирии - РИА Новости

1 Share

РИА Новости

США знают о стремлении России к серьезному военному сотрудничеству по Сирии
РИА Новости
ВАШИНГТОН, 26 авг — РИА Новости, Дмитрий Злодорев. США знают о стремлении РФ к более серьезному военному сотрудничеству по Сирии, но считают, что этому мешает поддержка Москвы правительства президента Башара Асада, заявил в пятницу официальный представитель ...
США: Поддержка Россией Асада затрудняет мирное разрешение кризиса в СирииВзгляд
Белый дом: действия военных моряков Ирана являются неприемлемымиТАСС
Белый дом: США не нужны российские уступки по СирииВести.Ru
ИА REGNUM -Федеральное агентство новостей No.1 -inoСМИ.Ru -Аргументы.ру
Все похожие статьи: 21 »

A Baker’s Dozen of Neglected Russian Stories – No. 46

1 Share


Paul Goble

         Staunton, August 26 -- The flood of news stories from a country as large, diverse and strange as the Russian Federation often appears to be is far too large for anyone to keep up with. But there needs to be a way to mark those which can’t be discussed in detail but which are too indicative of broader developments to ignore.

          Consequently, Windows on Eurasia presents a selection of 13 of these other and typically neglected stories at the end of each week. This is the 46thsuch compilation. It is only suggestive and far from complete – indeed, once again, one could have put out such a listing every day -- but perhaps one or more of these stories will prove of broader interest.

1.      Legal Problems for Putin? Many have suggested that the international community should use its legal powers against the Kremlin leader, but now such proposals are attracting more attention.  A Moscow commentator says US courts should bring charges against Vladimir Putin for his role in the 1999 apartment bombings (kasparov.ru/material.php?id=57B82C1B02DB3), Ukrainian officials have put Putin and his entourage on a wanted list (evrazia.org/news/46597), and some Russians are now calling for his impeachment, calls that have even appeared on Russian television (charter97.org/ru/news/2016/08/23/v-efire-rossiya-1-prizvali-k-impichmentu-putinu/).

2.      Russians Now Choose Patriotic Symbols Other than Putin for Their T-Shirts.  Fewer Russians are buying T-shirts with pictures of Vladimir Putin than did two years ago, choosing instead other patriotic symbols (themoscowtimes.com/articles/corps-couture-the-rise-of-russias-patriotic-fashion-industry-54983).  But there are some problems with these other symbols: Most Russians tell pollsters they aren’t prepared to fly the Russian flag (club-rf.ru/news/42963), and some even are tearing down the Russian tri-color when it is put up in front of government buildings (regnum.ru/news/accidents/2169360.html).

3.      ‘Putin’s Elections are Less Democratic than Soviet Ones Were.’  A  Russian commentator says that elections under Vladimir Putin are less democratic in some ways than Soviet ones were because at least in Soviet times one could vote against all candidates (newsland.com/community/3782/content/nemnogo-o-vyborakh-v-sssr/5405327). In other election news, two-thirds of Russians don’t think their votes or anything else will affect the state’s actions (http://svpressa.ru/politic/article/155109/), and one in five is prepared to sell his or her vote in an election few think will lead to any real change (themoscowtimes.com/news/one-fifth-of-russians-ready-to-sell-their-votes-55058http://svpressa.ru/politic/article/155109/).

4.      Russians Cut Spending on Almost Everything Except Cosmetics.  As the Russian economic crisis deepens, most Russians are being forced to cut back on their purchases. But surveys show that one area where they are not cutting back in any significant way is in the purchase of cosmetics. Apparently, and in the best tradition of “hybrid” Russia, it is important to look good even if you don’t have enough to eat (profile.ru/obsch/item/109573-krasota-pervoj-neobkhodimosti).  Business bankrupticies are increasing (kasparov.ru/material.php?id=57BA9EC8ED180). One businessman took hostages in a Moscow bank to protest how he has been treated (kasparov.ru/material.php?id=57BDDDD6236BE). Prices continue to rise (ng.ru/economics/2016-08-22/4_prices.html). Strikes and protests are becoming more numerous (tvrain.ru/news/shahtery-415791/). But the government continues to discourage private efforts to address problems: fining people in Astrakhan for trying to fix local roads that the authorities have allowed to deteriorate (inforesist.org/v-rossii-samovolnyiy-remont-dorogi-privel-k-shtrafu/) even though they appear to be less concerned about the efforts of smugglers to repair roads so that they can bring in contraband more easily (themoscowtimes.com/news/traffickers-repair-russian-road-used-for-smuggling-55065). Perhaps someone is being paid off for that.

5.      Moscow Says US Sent Genetically Modified ‘Mutants’ to Olympics.  A Russian defense ministry official explains the US victories at Rio by saying that the American team included genetically modified “mutants” specially designed for victory (tvzvezda.ru/news/201608221615-81mu.htm/content/201608241747-ru46.htm). Meanwhile, in another Olympic story, many Russian outlets complained that the plane carrying the Russian team was detained for some hours on the tarmac of the Rio airport. What was not reported except in social media was that there was a problem: the Russian team failed to see that it could get its super-sized matryoshka doll on board by taking it apart (facebook.com/roma.lisovich?fref=nf&pnref=story.unseen-section).

6.      Russia Must Combat the Spread of English in Russia and Abroad.  A Russian commentator says that the spread of English around the world is anything but a natural phenomenon and that Moscow must set as one of its most important tasks blocking the spread of English first and foremost within Russia but also in other countries as well (ruskline.ru/analitika/2016/08/24/yazykovuyu_politiku_dolzhny_opredelyat_ideologi/).

7.      Now You Can Buy a Kalashnikov Right at the Moscow Airport.  The Kalashnikov weapons maker has opened a shop at Sheremetyevo so that those travelling through it can pick up a Kalashnikov even before exiting the confines of the airport itself (themoscowtimes.com/news/gun-maker-kalashnikov-opens-moscow-airport-shop-55041).

8.      Moscow Tells Parents of Soldiers Killed in Syria Their Children Died in the North Caucasus. To hide the number of Russian combat deaths in Syria, Russian officials are telling the parents of those who died there than in fact their sons died in the North Caucasus – even when parents know that their sons were not serving there (newsader.com/29546-kreml-vydaet-gibel-rossiyskikh-sold/).

9.      Russian Politics Gets Really Down and Dirty.  Those who don’t like the reporting of journalists like Yuliya Latynina are now using a new tactic against them: throwing fecal materials at them in the streets of Moscow (graniru.org/Society/Media/m.253898.html).

10.  WillThere Now Be Charges of a ‘Jewish-Pokemon Conspiracy’?  The rabbi at the St. Petersburg synagogue has offered a bottle of kosher wine for those who are able to track down Pokemons nearby, an action that not surprisingly has triggered the usual kind of Russian commentaries given how many Russian officials and commentators have suggested that Pokemon is a Western plot against Russia (rueconomics.ru/185746-peterburgskaya-sinagoga-poobeshchala-butylku-koshernogo-vina-za-lovlyu-pokemonov?utm_source=rnews&_utl_t=fb).

11.  Volgograd Officials Ready to Rename Airport There ‘Stalingrad.’  Officials in the former city of Tsaritsyn, then Stalingrad, and now Volgograd say they are ready to rename the airport there in honor of the late Soviet dictator, something that has sparked both expressions of support and outbursts of anger (slon.ru/posts/72401).  (7x7-journal.ru/post/85886).  Meanwhile, in Oryol, a scandal is brewing because officials apparently manipulated poll results in order to suggest that people there really wanted a statue of Ivan the Terrible when in fact it appears likely that most don't(7x7-journal.ru/post/85886). 

12.  Moscow has New Problems with India and Iran of Its Own Making.  Indian officials say that one in six of the Russian warplanes Delhi has purchased don’t work (newsader.com/29532-pronizany-problemami-indiya-obyavila/), and Iranian officials say that Moscow was supposed to keep its use of an Iranian airbase secret, something Russian officials didn’t do (graniru.org/Politics/Russia/m.253975.html).

13.  Marie Antoinette was a Piker: Russian Officials Eat Cake Intended for Orphans.  Just when one assumes that Russian officials can’t top their Marie Antoinette behavior, they nonetheless do. This week, officials in Sakha ate all of a cake that had been prepared for orphans, leaving the children with nothing (m.gazeta.ru/social/news/2016/08/23/n_9029213.shtml). This kind of thoughtless and cruel behavior is becoming ever more common, Russian journalists say (momenty.org/people/i166828/) and has led some officials to suggest that the media should be told not to talk about the growing gap between rich and poor in Russia lest it spark social tensions (vedomosti.ru/economics/articles/2016/08/24/654247-informatsiya-bonusah-top-menedzherov-kompanii-mozhet-usilit-sotsialnuyu-napryazhennost-tsb).

            And six more from countries near Russia:

1.      Ukrainian Army Drops Soviet-Style Hats and Uniforms.  De-communization in Ukraine is proceeding apace, with ever more Lenin statues taken down and places renamed for Ukrainian heroes rather than Soviet criminals (forum-msk.org/material/news/12157339.html). But perhaps the most obvious sign of Ukraine’s turn away from Moscow is that Ukrainian soldiers are no longer wearing uniforms and hats like those of the Soviet and Russian armies (apostrophe.com.ua/article/society/2016-08-22/general-iz-nato-sotsseti-prishli-v-vostorg-ot-novoy-formyi-stepana-poltoraka/6946).

2.      Zhirinovsky Says Russia Should Attack Ukraine When US Votes. LDPR leader Vladimir Zhirinovsky says that Moscow should attack Ukraine as Americans vote in their presidential election so that Washington, being distracted, won’t do anything to help Kyiv (http://www.dsnews.ua/politics/zhirinovskiy-putin-dolzhen-napast-na-ukrainu-vo-vremya-vyborov-19082016100200).

3.      Kerch Bridge Won’t Last Even If It is Built, Ukrainian Expert Says.  Even if Moscow does manage to build the Kerch bridge to Crimea, something that is far from certain, a Ukrainian engineer says, the bridge will almost certainly be destroyed by the actions of currents in the waters there (focus.ua/world/348338/).

4.      Ukrainian Olympian Wanted to Put a Missile Blowing Up Moscow on His Canoe.  One measure of how Ukrainians feel about Russia’s invasion of their country surfaced at the Rio Olympiad.  A Ukrainian canoeist wanted to put a picture of a missile blowing up Moscow on his boat, but he was dissuaded from doing so by Olympic officials (112.international/sport/ukraines-olympic-champion-wanted-his-canoe-with-picture-of-missile-blown-up-in-moscow-8744.html).

5.      ‘Armenian-Russian Friendship Museum Must Be Renamed Because Armenian-Russian Friendship Doesn’t Exist.’ Yerevan residents say that the museum devoted to Armenian-Russian friendship in their city must be renamed because such friendship does not now exist (ru.1in.am/1163352.html).

6.      ‘World Fears Russia Not Because It is Strong But Because It is Insane,’ Landsbergis Says. Lithuanian independence leader Vytautas Landsbergis says that it is important for both Russia and the world to understand that “the world now fears Russia not because it is strong but because it is insane” (tvrain.ru/teleshow/interview/landsbergis-415649/).  At least some Russians agree: Samara residents want their governor examined by a psychiatrist after his recent claims about a CIA conspiracy directed against that oblast (club-rf.ru/63/news/43030).


Read the whole story

· · · · · · ·

Russian Aggression, Not Maidan, Behind Growing Ukrainian Hostility toward Russia, Studies Show

1 Share


Paul Goble

            Staunton, August 26 – Moscow propagandists have long insisted that Ukrainians became hostile to Russia as a result of what they say was the Western-organized Maidan, but sociological research clearly shows that it was not the Maidan but rather subsequent Russian aggression that caused Ukrainians to change their attitude toward Russia and Russians.

            Ukrainians now view Russians as an enemy rather than as a fraternal people, a dramatic shift that was highlighted this week by President Petro Poroshenko’s remarks on Ukrainian Independence Day and that has been documented by Ukrainian sociologists and other scholars in recent studies and polls.

            Ukrainian political analyst Yevgeny Magda sums up these changes in the following way: “Russian-Ukrainian relations have changed forever,” he says, and “the formula, ‘we will no longer be brothers’ is appropriate: There is thus no reason to speak about the restoration of good-neighborly relations in the foreseeable future” (news.online.ua/751100/chestno-o-shansah-na-pobedu-shest-glavnyh-slov-o-voyne-ukrainy-za-nezavisimost/).

            Russia’s aggression against Ukraine has transformed the situation, Magda continues, “and it is important for Ukraine to show to the rest of the world that in fact it was a colony of Russia and not a republic equal to the RSFSR in the former Soviet Union,” as Russian propagandists regularly insist.

            But as insightful as these observations are, it is important to have more objective measures of just how and perhaps especially when Ukrainian attitudes toward Russia and Russians have changed. That is now possible because of the rapidly maturing polling sector in Ukraine.

            The QHA news agency summarizes the reports of Ukrainian sociologists that were presented at a meeting last week organized by the Kucheriv Democratic Initiative Foundation at the Institute of Sociology of the Ukrainian Academy of Sciences (qha.com.ua/ru/politika/kak-priklad-ekspansii-rf-razbil-vitraj-ukrainskih-simpatii/164678/; for the complete report of their findings (in Ukrainian), seedif.org.ua/ua/publications/press-relizy/do-dnja-nezalezhno.htm).

            The sociologists reported that the latest surveys show that 60 percent of those questioned said that they were proud to be Ukrainians. Only 16 percent said they were not. Those figures are far higher than in the 1990s, and the situation began to change at the time first of the Orange Revolution and then at that of the Maidan.

            The highest figure in this regard – 67 percent – was reached in 2015. It has fallen off somewhat as Ukrainians recognize that the situation they find themselves in is likely to last a long time and be filled with uncertainties, the sociologists say. They also stress that it is significant that 22 percent of those surveyed identify more with a city or village than with the country, but only seven percent with a region more than with Ukraine as a whole.

            Yevgeny Golovakha, the deputy director of the Kyiv Institute of Sociology, said at the meeting that Ukrainians today feel hope and only then concern and that now “hope is even more the predominant feeling than was the case in the relati8vely stable and well-off period of the beginning of 2013.”

            In that year, 32 percent of Ukrainians said they were hopeful about their country; now 44 percent do. He also noted that ever fewer Ukrainians are interested in any integration with Russia: “Fewer than 20 percent of the respondents” favor that now, and “up to 57 percent” say they are opposed to some kind of hypothetical “’Slavic union’” of Ukraine, Belarus and Russia.

            Irina Bekeshkin, head of the Democratic Initiative Foundation pointed out that this is a reversal of the situation in 1998 when 60 percent of Ukrainians favored such an arrangement. In her view, QHA says, “the decisive role in this shift was played not by the Dignity Revolution but by the aggression of Russia.”

            She added that ever more Ukrainians look to integrate with Western institutions like the EU and NATO. A majority now expect their country to be in the EU 20 years from now.  And the number of those favoring NATO membership now equals the number opposed, a radical shift even from as recently as 2006.

            Ukrainian sociology and polling have suffered from the problems of youth, QHA says, but they are not alone in that. Some of the most distinguished Russian polling agencies also do things that sociologists elsewhere would reject as problematic or worse.

            The article gives the example of a recent Levada Center poll which found that 58 percent of Russians are now hostile to Ukraine and only 31 percent are positive as an example of such problems (levada.ru/2016/08/22/vospriyatie-ssha-ukrainy-i-zhitelej-etih-gosudastv/) because the Moscow pollsters asked about Russian attitudes toward Ukraine while also asking about their attitudes toward the US and the EU.

            Given that Kremlin outlets insist that “in the Donbass, Russia is fighting not so much with Ukraine as with the entire Western world,” asking the question about Russian attitudes toward Ukraine and Ukrainians is a kind of “manipulation,” something Ukrainian pollsters would be criticized for even if Russian ones aren’t.


Read the whole story

· · · ·

Russians Still Leaving Kazakhstan But Now for Personal Not Political Reasons, New Study Says

1 Share


Paul Goble

            Staunton, August 26 – Although the number of people leaving Kazakhstan for permanent residence elsewhere has declined by an order of magnitude over the last 15 years, more than half of those who are leaving are ethnic Russians going to the Russian Federation. But mainly, they are going for personal rather than political reasons, according to Olga Semakova.

            In a major new study contained in a special issue on various migration flows in Kazakhstan, the Kazakhstan sociologist reports on the reasons ethnic Russians continue to leave her country even though the total numbers of those departing are far below what they were (kisi.kz/uploads/33/files/348Has08.pdf, pp. 7-42; summarized at 365info.kz/2016/08/60-russkih-kazahstana-ne-hotyat-uezzhat-isledovanie/).

In the first decade after the disintegration of the USSR, some 2.5 million people, most of them ethnic Russians, left Kazakhstan. At the end of the 1990s, approximately 300,000 people were leaving each year; now, approximately 30,000 are doing so, a decline equal to an order of magnitude.”

“According to official statistics,” Semakova says, over the last five years, 104,407 ethnic Russians out of a total of 146,052 have left Kazakhstan, while 16,883 ethnic Russians have come to Kazakhstan, out of a total number of arrivals of 123,871. Ethnic Russians thus form 44.5 percent of the total amount of immigration and emigration from the country.

Semakova argues that some 60 percent of ethnic Russians in Kazakhstan do not want to leave while 36 percent say they would like to. That latter figure, however, says little about whether or when they will do so. Fewer than one in five (18 percent) of those who say they want to leave say that they will do so within the next two years.

The ethnic Russians most likely to leave are those with higher educations between the ages of 30 and 49, with those 18 to 29, the prime child-bearing cohort being only slightly less interested in leaving Kazakhstan and moving to the Russian Federation so that their children can grow up in a Russian milieu.

According to Semakova, there are three “blocks” of things pushing people and especially ethnic Russians to leave Kazakhstan. The most important of these are social-economic conditions about jobs and social welfare. Many Russians feel they can’t make a career in Kazakhstan, and most see social welfare conditions in Russia as better.

The next most important are family and personal considerations. Ethnic Russians sometimes want to move to be closer to family members, but the key factor here, Semakova says, involves educational and life chances for their children, chances that ethnic Russians in Kazakhstan assume are better in Russia than where they are now.

The third block, “motives of  political character” including interethnic relations” is much less significant and has an impact an order of magnitude less than the other two on decisions about emigration, the sociologist says.


Read the whole story

· ·

Petrov on How Cadres Decisions are Made in the Kremlin Now

1 Share


Paul Goble

            Staunton, August 26 – Appointments and dismissals of key officials provide insights into how the Kremlin makes decisions more generally because in contrast to other sectors, hirings and firings are almost always carried out, Nikolay Petrov says, adding that the recent wave of changes at the top thus provides a large amount of data on these key aspects of the Putin system.

            Two weeks ago, Petrov, the head of the Moscow Center for Political-Geographic Research, published an article in which he outlined what he sees as the emergence of a neo-nomenklatura system that is gradually moving from a Brezhnevite to a Stalainist model. (On this, seewindowoneurasia2.blogspot.com/2016/08/putins-neo-nomenklatura-system-shifts.html.)

                He has now followed this up with a discussion of how cadres decisions are now taken in the Kremlin and what that says about Vladimir Putin’s intentions and the future development of his system (vedomosti.ru/opinion/articles/2016/08/24/654236-novaya-nomenklatura-prinyatie-reshenii).

            Both the most recent wave of personnel changes and “the large series of cadres decisions of the last two years look consistent and well thought out, a pattern that testifies at a minimum that they have been taken within the framework of a common logic and from a single center.” And while Putin has the last word, he does not make all these choices independently.

            That task is simply too large: “the nomenklatura positions the president appoints have increased sharly” and the number of presidential representatives both formal and informal, including in essence the governors has grown as well.” But Putin sets the direction and the parameters within which all these choices are made.

            “The personal participation of the president in the adoption of cadres decisions doesn’t mean one man rule and his absolute independence in taking them,” Petrov says. Various groups in the bureaucracy are involved, and Putin can’t ignore them. Many decisions are thus “the result of a struggle in the apparatus and competition of various groups within the elite.”

            Putin is a past master at patience, Petetrov argues. He thinks about cadres appointments for a long time and “tests the reaction to possible appointments on various people from his entourage.” He could dispense with this perhaps, but he has to take various factors into consideration – image, balance, message, and so on – and testing names on others is helpful.

            A particular reason he has to do that, the analyst suggests, is that cadres changes at the top involve cadres changes below. When one leader is replace by another, that has consequences for others who have been or will become their subordinates.  It is best if this is considered in advance rather than after the fact.

            The timing of appointments, Petrov says, can be triggered either by objective external circumstances or by “subjective factors,” including personal relationships.  Often people are changed not because of themselves but because of a new direction in overall Kremlin policy in a particular area. “The real goals [involved] typically aren’t announced.”

            The only cadres appointments where the process has been specified in law concerns the naming of governors. There the 2004 rules are generally followed but not always, especially if key groups lobby for or against a particular appointment or reappointment directly with the president. Then almost anything can happen.

            According to Petrov, the most important change in the cadres process in recent times involves a shift from carrots to sticks. In the past, the Kremlin generally used a system of carrots, offering someone on the way out something else. Now, what has emerged is a system involving sticks “or their absence.”

            That increases the likelihood that the system will move in one of two directions in the coming months: either in the direction of “authoritarianism for which a shift to mass repressions regarding cadres will be necessary or toward authoritarian modernization in which cadres will have to bend the knee and adapt.”

            Which one will occur, Petrov says, is uncertain, but he suggests that “we should be able to see it already before the end of the year.”

Read the whole story

· · ·

Kerry, Russian Counterpart Try to Hammer Out Syria Plan

1 Share
The United States and Russia renewed efforts Friday to negotiate a peaceful end to the fighting in Syria in light of a more volatile and complicated situation with the introduction of Turkish forces on the ground. U.S. Secretary of State John Kerry and Russian Foreign Minister Sergei Lavrov
are meeting in Geneva, trying to come to an agreement over military cooperation and information sharing in a bid to defeat Islamic State militants in Syria - something both sides want.   As they took a lunchtime break, Lavrov said the talks on Syria with Kerry were “excellent.” The U.N. envoy for Syria, Staffan de Mistura, who joined the Friday’s closely-watched U.S.-Russia meeting in the early afternoon, said after the break, “We are still working.”   As he entered the morning session, Lavrov avoided commenting on a reporter’s question of what was the primary impediment to a cease-fire in Syria, only saying, "I don't want to spoil the atmosphere for the negotiations." Kerry did not make any comments.   It was not immediately clear if either man would address reporters after their talks, which include discussions about the crisis in Ukraine.   Previous rounds of
international negotiations, including discussions between the top diplomats from Washington and
Moscow, have failed to produce an end to the conflict in Syria, which is complicated by U.S. and Russian support for opposite
sides and has killed more than 290,000 people. The conflict also has forced millions from their homes in more than five years. Heightened regional tensions Kerry's initial plan, unveiled during July talks in Moscow, would have Washington and Moscow coordinate airstrikes against Islamic State fighters and stop the Syrian air force from launching any further air attacks. The latest meeting comes amid heightened tensions in Syria after Turkey decided earlier this week to send tanks across the border into Syria to clear out a pocket of land controlled by the Islamic State group. U.S.-backed Syrian Kurdish fighters say they are withdrawing to their bases east of the Euphrates River after Turkey's military and allied fighters launched a cross-border offensive. The Kurdish rebels have been a source of tension between the U.S., which views them as a key ally in the war in Syria, and Turkey, which sees them as terrorists allied with separatist Turkish Kurd factions.  A U.S.-led coalition spokesman said the Kurds moved east "to prepare for the eventual liberation of Raqqa." It is unclear, however, if all the Kurdish forces have withdrawn as Turkey had demanded ahead of its offensive. The head of the Britain-based Syrian Observatory for Human Rights, Rami Abdel Rahman, told Arab media that Kurdish militia fighters are still fighting on the western side of the Euphrates River and had even captured some ground. Turkey's foreign minister said Kerry had spoken with him in a phone call early Thursday and said the Syrian Kurdish forces would withdraw. Vice President Joe Biden this week told Turkey's leaders the Kurds would lose U.S.-support if they did not move back across the Euphrates. Russia's Foreign Ministry expressed deep concern about the Turkish border operation, especially Turkey's targeting of Kurdish militia fighters. It said that Turkey, by targeting both Islamic State militants and Syrian Kurds, could further inflame the Syrian civil war, leading to "flare-ups of inter-ethnic tensions between Kurds and Arabs." Middle East analyst Theodore Karasik told VOA Turkey's military offensive on Syrian territory risks further complicating the war, influencing the shifting alliances among various militia factions that have made it difficult for any one side to dominate the conflict. He says Turkey risks escalating the conflict. Reporter Ed Yeranian contributed from Cairo.


Read the whole story

· · ·
Next Page of Stories
Loading...
Page 3

Iran Investigates Young Men at Risk of Being Recruited by IS

1 Share
Iran's intelligence minister says security officers have investigated more than 1,500 young men at risk of being recruited by the extremist Islamic State group. The semi-official Tasnim news agency on Friday quoted Mahmoud Alavi as saying that his department has summoned for questioning, detained or talked with the young people to stop them from joining IS.   Alavi didn't elaborate but says his officers are closely watching those who show an inclination toward joining the extremist group fighting in Iraq and Syria.   In recent months, Iran has executed or killed dozens of extremist Islamic "terrorists'' in clashes in the country's western regions.   In June, Iran claimed breaking up one of the "biggest terrorist plots'' ever on its soil by Sunni extremists planning bombings in Tehran and elsewhere.

Philippines, Rebels Sign Cease-fire Deal

1 Share
The Philippine government and the country’s Communist guerrillas have signed an indefinite cease-fire agreement. The truce, signed in Norway Friday, seeks to end one of Asia's longest-running insurgencies. It has claimed the lives of thousands of people.   "This is a historic and unprecedented event," said Jesus Dureza, the peace adviser to Philippine President Rodrigo Duterte. Dureza also said, "There is still a lot of work to be done ahead." The two sides have been meeting in Oslo since Monday and will meet again in October. Norwegian Foreign Minister Borge Brende described the deal as a "major breakthrough."

For Afghan Women, ‘Glass Is Half Full’

1 Share
As the United States prepared to invade Taliban-ruled Afghanistan 15 years ago, then-first lady Laura Bush took over her husband's weekly radio address to tell the American people that part of the reason for going to war after the attacks of September 11, 2001, was to liberate Afghan women from the brutality that had been forced on them by the extremists' regime. As the war against the Taliban grinds on, Afghan women are still largely treated as property and barely a week goes by without news emerging of a woman or girl being stoned to death, burned with gasoline, beaten or tortured by her in-laws, traded to repay a debt, jailed for running away from a violent husband, or sold into marriage as a child. Abuse of women in Afghanistan remains entrenched and endemic, despite constitutional guarantees of equality, protection from violence and age-old practices such as trading young women to pay debts. Earlier this month, news emerged from remote central Ghor province of Zarah, a pregnant 14-year-old who was allegedly tortured and set on fire by her in-laws as they took revenge on her father over a failed deal to marry one of their relatives. Mohammad Azam, 45, traveled to the capital, Kabul, to call for justice for the killing of his daughter. Yet he too had taken a young bride as payment for construction work. Rising violence reported The British government said in a report in early July that "documented cases of violence against women have risen'' in the first half of 2016, with 5,132 cases reported to the Afghanistan Independent Human Rights Commission, "including 241 murders." Attending a small rally in western Kabul to support Azam's call for justice, women's rights activist Veeda Saghari said violence against women is largely ignored by Afghanistan's judicial sector. "That is why all kinds of violence against women such as acid throwing, beating, stoning, informal community tribunal verdicts, burning, forced divorces, forced marriages, forced pregnancies, forced abortions have reached a peak,'' she said. In fairness, much has improved for Afghan women since the Taliban were ejected from power. During five years of Taliban rule, women were not permitted to attend school or work, were largely confined to their homes, and subject to public beatings for violations of strict rules on what they could wear in public. When it came to their health, very few had access to doctors, and benchmarks such as maternal mortality were among the worst in the world. Now millions of girls go to school, compared to practically none in 2001, and access to health care is widespread. The constitution protects women from the worst excesses they suffered before 2001. Figures published by the World Bank show a drop in maternal mortality, for instance, from 1,340 per 100,000 live births in 1990 to 396 in 2015. Many women work for the government and security services, run their own businesses, and are elected to parliament. Figures from President Ashraf Ghani's office show 33 percent of all teachers are women, and there are 240 women judges. He has nominated four women as Cabinet ministers, appointed seven as deputy ministers and four as ambassadors. Struggles continue Yet for most Afghan women, the struggles of today are little different to those under the Taliban. Many working women are targeted and often killed by extremists. High-profile lawmaker Shukria Barakzai, who ran a secret school for girls during the Taliban era, survived a suicide bomb attack in 2014, and was appointed ambassador to Norway last year. But in impoverished and rural areas, girls can often be of less value to their families than their animals. A burns unit in the western city of Herat has a ward dedicated to treating young women who set themselves on fire, as much a cry for help as a suicide attempt. Women's prisons in major cities, including Kabul, hold hundreds of women accused of adultery for having sex outside marriage, as well as young women who have run away from home to escape arranged marriages or abusive, often much older, husbands. Phumzile Mlambo-Ngcuka, the executive director of U.N. Women, has found that government officials, judges, clerics and educators are often receptive to the concepts of women's rights, as enshrined in the Afghan constitution. But, she said, "When we are dealing with extremism, there is pushback. Every step of the way, there is pushback.'' Resisting forced values Following the fall of the Taliban, the Western push for women's rights led some Afghans to feel that Western values were being forced on them, she said, and that had led to problems of acceptance of women's rights as homegrown. The situation is complicated by almost 40 years of conflict. "We have a generation that has only known war, and at the same time you also have a generation that has been educated, that knows about the lives that are lived by people in other parts of the world. There has to be some confusion as people try to deal with all these issues,'' Mlambo-Ngcuka said, adding: "So the glass is half full.'' That doesn't mean Afghanistan should be given special treatment, she said. "Rape is rape, physical violence is physical violence. So in our quest not to be overbearing and not to overshadow local efforts, I don't think that we should also move away and not talk about the universality of rights," she said. As a member of the United Nations and signatory to the "same charters as all the other member states, we have to hold them to the same standards because the nation has actually signed on to the same value system as the other nations," she said. "What is good for a child in Europe in terms of protection, in terms of making sure that they have a right to education, not to be married early – that is good for a child in Europe and it is good for a child in Afghanistan.''

Read the whole story

· · · ·

Syrian Civilians, Fighters Evacuated From Daraya

1 Share
Syrian government buses on Friday began evacuating the first of 4,000 civilians and rebel fighters from the rebel-held Damascus suburb of Daraya. Fighters reportedly will be allowed to leave for rebel-held Idlib province, near the Turkish border, based on a deal reached with government representatives Thursday. Syrian state TV showed live footage of the first green government bus leaving the besieged suburb. Several bearded rebel fighters could be seen in the bus, alongside their families. A Syrian army colonel overseeing the operation told journalists that it was proceeding smoothly and that he hoped it would be a precursor to similar actions. He said the first batch of 300 rebel fighters, whom he called "terrorists", were being evacuated to the rebel-held province of Idlib. He added that some civilians who wish to remain in the Damascus area would be allowed to do so. Syrian media reported that approximately 4,000 remaining residents of Daraya – under government siege since 2012 – would leave the area under a deal. A quarter-million people lived in the suburb before the Syrian conflict broke out in 2011. Preparations observed Amateur video taken by opposition activists inside Daraya showed women dressed in black veils surrounded by children preparing to leave. Young men in military fatigues also milled around the heavily damaged buildings surrounded by piles of rubble. Convoys of four-wheel-drive vehicles and ambulances belonging to the Syrian Red Crescent organization also took part in the operation to evacuate the wounded and a number of dead government troops. Syrian state media reported that some of the fighters being evacuated had agreed to surrender to the government and accept an official amnesty. VOA could not independently confirm the claim. Four-day operation planned Pro-Syrian government al-Mayadeen TV reported that 45 government buses would participate in what it called a four-day operation to evacuate all remaining individuals from Daraya. It reported that other Damascus suburbs may soon participate in similar evacuation operations. Saudi-owned al-Arabiya TV, which supports the rebels, reported that more than 3,000 people have been killed in Daraya since it came under government siege in 2012.

Read the whole story

· ·

The Correspondents

1 Share
The Correspondents is VOA’s weekly discussion of the world’s top stories, as seen through the eyes of our dedicated reporters in the US and around the globe. Hosted by Mil Arcega, our panel of journalists goes beyond the headlines to give listeners and viewer real context and understanding of what’s driving the story.

Fake Trump Quote Goes Viral in Russian Media

1 Share
Russian media outlets on Thursday quoted U.S. Republican party presidential candidate Donald Trump as harshly criticizing the International Paralympic Committee’s decision to ban Russian athletes from the 2016 Paralympics, which will be held in Rio de Janeiro starting on September 7. The problem is that these comments attributed to Trump appear to have been made up. Citing the British Broadcasting Corporation, several dozen Russian newspapers, TV channels and radio stations quoted Trump as saying that the decision to bar Russian athletes from the Paralympics was made by “complete idiots who are the real disabled people.” Trump was further quoted as saying: “How else to explain the fact that athletes from Russia, where there were scandals involving doping, were at the Olympic games in Rio, but that all the Russian Paralympic athletes, who were not connected with doping scandals, will not be there? To work off their own uselessness on disabled people from Russia, strong of body and spirit – is this not mean and low?” Had Donald Trump made such a statement, it would have been big news in his presidential campaign. So, VOA’s Russian Service asked the Interfax news agency, which had also quoted the putative Trump comment and attributed it to the BBC, for comment. VOA also asked the BBC about it. ‘Released by mistake’ Shortly after being contacted by VOA, Interfax withdrew its report on the alleged Trump quote, saying it had been “released by mistake” and apologizing to subscribers. A short time later, BBC’s press service, in response to VOA’s inquiry, confirmed that it had not published any report claiming to quote Donald Trump criticizing those who banned Russian athletes from participating in the upcoming Paralympics in Rio. An Internet search found that the first reference to the alleged BBC report appeared on August 23 on a website which, in the past, had posted news reports that turned out to be fictional. Still, the Trump “quote” quickly spread across the Russian Internet after it was reported Thursday by the popular Russian sports portal Sovsport. In addition to major outlets, the alleged Trump quote was reported by the Russian government newspaper Rossiyskaya Gazeta and by Parlamentskaya Gazeta, which is published by the Russian parliament. The former attributed the quote to “News reports,” the latter – to the BBC. The quote was welcomed by Russian netizens with comments like "Bravo, Trump!", "Well done, Trump!", "I like Trump more and more, and on this issue he is totally great!", and even "a word of truth from America!" After Interfax withdrew its report, Russian media outlets, one by one, followed suite, telling their readers they had been the victims of a fraud perpetrated by “internet pranksters.” Still, some outlets left the quote standing, among them the government’s Rossiyskaya Gazeta. Later Thursday evening, it did publish a separate report acknowledging that the story “could have been fake.” Parlamentskaya Gazeta also left the story up but without any immediate corrections or disclaimers.

Read the whole story

· · ·
Next Page of Stories
Loading...
Page 4

RBC Publishes Report Sourced in FSB and Military on Wagner Private Military Contractor with 2,500 Fighters in Syria

1 Share
LIVE UPDATES: The Russian news service RBC has published an extensive report on Wagner, a private military contractor with 2,500 fighters deployed in Syria. They have also served in Ukraine.
Welcome to our column, Russia Update, where we will be closely following day-to-day developments in Russia, including the Russian government’s foreign and domestic policies.
The previous issue is here.
Recent Analysis and Translations:
UPDATES BELOW

Ukrainian Civilian Volunteer Killed by Sniper in Shirokino; Maryinka is Town Most Under Fire 

1 Share
Ukraine Day 921: LIVE UPDATES BELOW.
Yesterday’s live coverage of the Ukraine conflict can be found here.
    READ OUR SPECIAL REPORT:


Power Vertical Podcast: The Tale Of The Tape 

1 Share
Sometimes it takes awhile for the historical record to become clear.
Sometimes it takes time for the things we have long suspected — and even assumed — to be confirmed.
Sometimes it takes years to fill in the blanks.
That’s exactly what happened this week when Ukrainian prosecutors released recordings of intercepted telephone conversations between Kremlin aide Sergei Glazyev and proxies in Ukraine.
In the intercepts, Glazyev gives detailed instructions about instigating unrest in Donetsk, Kharkiv, Zaporizhia, and Odesa as early as February 2014.
So what did we learn from the Glazyev tapes? And what are the implications?
On this week’s Power Vertical Podcast, I discuss these revelations with co-host Mark Galeotti, a senior research fellow at the Czech Institute of International Relations in Prague, a visiting fellow at the European Council on Foreign Relations, and author of the blog In Moscow’s Shadows, and guests Andreas Umland of the Institute for Euro-Atlantic Cooperation in Kyiv and Anton Shekhovtsov, a visiting fellow at the Institute for Human Sciences in Vienna.
Enjoy …

Listen to or download the podcast above or subscribe to The Power Vertical Podcast on iTunes.
Read the whole story

Italy Earthquake: Death toll reaches 278 while road damage could see town 'isolated' 

1 Share
Three Britons - a teenager and a married couple - are named among victims as hopes fade of finding survivors

Read the whole story

· · ·

The dark web is a dangerous new frontier for those who try to keep terrorists at bay 

1 Share
A man has been arrested for allegedly supplying a gun to the teenager behind the recent Munich attack via the dark web - but the use of such websites can make tracking of weapons difficult

Read the whole story

· · ·

Зачем Кадыров прилетал в Кремль? 

1 Share
From: SvobodaRadio
Duration: 00:00

Визит Рамзана Кадырова в Москву обсуждаем с Александром Осовцовым, экс депутатом Госдумы и участником событий в Буденновске, политологом Русланом Мартаговым, журналистом Саидом Бицоевым и Еленой Масюк, бывшим военным корреспондентом, членом ОНК Москвы.
Ведущий - Владимир Кара-Мурза-старший.
Next Page of Stories
Loading...
Page 5

Детское порно и дело Буковского 

1 Share
From: SvobodaRadio
Duration: 30:01

Детское порно – идеальный инструмент компрометации. Кому понадобилось опорочить Владимира Буковского? В программе Александра Подрабинека «Дежавю» адвокат Вадим Клювгант, журналист Антон Носик, юрист Павел Строилов.
Видеотрансляция в пятницу в 18:30.

Зачем Кадыров прилетал в Кремль? 

1 Share
From: SvobodaRadio
Duration: 53:23

Визит Рамзана Кадырова в Москву обсуждаем с Александром Осовцовым, экс депутатом Госдумы и участником событий в Буденновске, политологом Русланом Мартаговым, журналистом Саидом Бицоевым.

Clinton cranks up Trump-Russia rhetoric as Election Day draws closer - RT

1 Share

RT

Clinton cranks up Trump-Russia rhetoric as Election Day draws closer
RT
In just over two months, the next US president will have been elected, and the mud-slinging will have finally come to an end. But until then, Hillary Clinton is throwing all the punches she can, continuing to accuse Donald Trump of having ties with Russia.

and more »

Germany urges restart to arms control agreement with Russia - RT

1 Share

RT

Germany urges restart to arms control agreement with Russia
RT
Steinmeier is part of the Social Democratic party, which usually takes more favorable stance towards Russia. The foreign minister came under fire from NATO in June after he accused the military alliance of “sabre-rattling and shrill war cries” that ...
German FM Steinmeier calls for new arms control pact with RussiaDeutsche Welle 


all 12
 German minister calls for new arms control agreement with RussiaEurActiv
German FM Calls for New Arms Control Deal to Avoid NATO-Russia Arms RaceSputnik International

all 9 news articles »

Russia ramps up campaign to discredit 'scum' doctor who blew whistle on doping conspiracy - National Post

1 Share

National Post

Russia ramps up campaign to discredit 'scum' doctor who blew whistle on doping conspiracy
National Post
MOSCOW — Enraged by its blanket ban from the Paralympic Games and the exclusion of scores of its athletes from the Olympic Games, Moscow is ramping up a campaign against aRussian doctor who provided detailed evidence of state-sponsored doping.

Rio 2016 Paralympics: Russia contest Court of Arbitration for Sport decisionBBC Sport
Russia to appeal against Rio ban in courtReuters

Putin Calls Ban on Russia's Paralympic Team InhumaneABC News 

NEWS.com.au-The Guardian
all 275 news articles »

Protests as Russia holds Crimea Tatar activist in psych ward - Yahoo News

1 Share

Yahoo News

Protests as Russia holds Crimea Tatar activist in psych ward
Yahoo News
Simferopol (AFP) - International rights groups and Ukrainian officials protested Friday against the incarceration in a psychiatric hospital of a prominent Crimean Tatar activist charged with calling for extremism in the Russian-annexed peninsula. Ilmi ...
Rights group urges Russia to release Crimean Tatar leaderU.S. News & World Report
Ukrainian bank to sue Russia for $1bn over lost Crimean assets & businessRT
Ukraine's Oschadbank files lawsuit against RussiaRussia Beyond the Headlines

all 23 news articles »
Next Page of Stories
Loading...
Page 6

Chinese Cyber Attacks on Russia Nearly Triple - Newsweek

1 Share

Newsweek

Chinese Cyber Attacks on Russia Nearly Triple
Newsweek
Despite numerous reports of Russian cyberattacks on the West in the last year, the country is also the target of plenty of hack attempts itself—from China, Bloomberg reports. Politically China and Russia have moved closer, as Moscow seeks to fill the ...

and more »

One year on, Russia's withdrawal from Syria looking unlikely - Deutsche Welle

1 Share

Deutsche Welle

One year on, Russia's withdrawal from Syria looking unlikely
Deutsche Welle
On August 26 last year, Moscow and Damascus signed an agreement on the deployment ofRussian warplanes and military personnel at the Khmeimim air base in Syria's Latakia province. This deal kick-started Russia's military intervention in the country on ...
EU should drop Russia sanctions, Slovak PM says after meeting PutinReuters
Russia to Conduct Military Drills Amid Ukraine TensionsWall Street Journal
Putin Orders Army Drills as Merkel Accuses Russia on UkraineBloomberg
RT-Russia Beyond the Headlines 

all 114
 Sputnik International
all 112 news articles »

Latvia's Wariness Over Russia Raises Civil Rights Concerns at Home - Wall Street Journal

1 Share

Wall Street Journal

Latvia's Wariness Over Russia Raises Civil Rights Concerns at Home
Wall Street Journal

RIGA, Latvia—In this former Soviet republic, two ostensibly tongue-in-cheek challenges to the nation's independence are causing trouble for the authors—and raising concerns about civil rights. Days after Deniss Barteckis posted an online petition ...


and more »

Erdogan, Putin Agree To Speed Up Aid For Aleppo

1 Share
Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdogan and Russia's Vladimir Putin have agreed in a phone call to accelerate efforts to deliver aid to Syria's Aleppo.

U.S.: Actions By Iranian Vessels In Gulf Increase 'Risks Of Miscalculation'

1 Share
The White House has expressed concern after several close encounters between Iranian vessels and U.S. warships in the Persian Gulf this week.

Slovakian Leader Renews Call For Ending EU Sanctions On Russia

1 Share
Slovak Prime Minister Robert Fico renewed his call for the European Union to end sanctions against Russia after a meeting this week with President Vladimir Putin in Moscow.

Next Page of Stories
Loading...
Page 7

Командующий войсками ЮВО проверяет выполнение мероприятий внезапной проверки в соединениях и воинских частях, дислоцированных в Крыму и Волгоградской области

1 Share
В Севастополе генерал-полковник Александр Дворников ознакомится с работой военкомата по выполнению мобилизационных заданий, организации территориальной обороны

Министр обороны встретился с армейскими спортсменами-триумфаторами Олимпийских игр в Рио

1 Share
На торжественном приёме в Центре управления национальной обороной страны генерал армии Сергей Шойгу наградил чемпионов и призеров игр ведомственными медалями и присвоил им очередные воинские звания.

Министр обороны России генерал армии Сергей Шойгу прибыл в Красноярск, где проверит исполнение Гособоронзаказа по производству межконтинентальных баллистических ракет

1 Share
Кроме того, командующий войсками ЦВО генерал-полковник Владимир Зарудницкий доложит об участии войск округа во внезапной проверке боеготовности.


Academic Plagiarism in a Country of Cynics 

1 Share
Beyond potential political allegiances and personal phobias, we should ask ourselves how serious is the alleged academic plagiarism attributed to President Enrique Peña Nieto by Carmen Aristegui.
According to the report presented by the journalist last Sunday on her website, the chief executive of the state plagiarized at least ten authors in his thesis “Mexican presidentialism and Alvaro Obregón” which he presented at the Pan American University for the completion of his bachelor's degree in Law.

Why We Need Kremlinology Again

1 Share
The increasing opacity of Russian politics has opened a window of opportunity for Kremlinology to make a comeback. Many people ridicule the field of study as little more than reading tea leaves, but it can be a helpful analytical tool when done properly.
The standard 
dictionary definition of Kremlinology
 is “the study of the policies and practices of the former Soviet government” (Merriam-Webster), rendering it synonymous with Sovietology. The Urban Dictionary offers a 
more relevant definition
: “The art of observing, deducing, and guessing what is really happening within a secretive organization.”
I see Kremlinology as the formalized study of hard facts in a closed society, observing appointments, organization, decrees, and formal speeches. Kremlinology has no role in an open society, but Russia today is no open society, though it is far from Soviet. The Kremlin offers plenty of information today, notably through President Vladimir Putin’s magnificent website, of which Steve Lee Myers has made eminent use in his book 
The New Tsar
, but disinformation thrives as never before, best illustrated by 
Peter Pomerantsev
.
In Stalin’s time, the world usually learned about ousters from the semiannual reviews at the Lenin Mausoleum on November 7 and May 1; Soviet newspapers published photos of the whole party elite on these occasions, providing a meticulous documentation of their ranking. Wondering how it was done, I attended an official reception of Prime Minister Nikolai Ryzhkov in 1987. When Ryzhkov arrived, the senior officials swiftly arranged themselves into their correct protocol positions. Protocol matters in closed hierarchical states, which Kremlinology utilizes.
Today, the Kremlin publishes multiple photos from top-level meetings, and it matters who attends and where they sit. When Putin gathered his Economic Council on May 25, liberal Alexei Kudrin sat far down the table, in a lower spot than hardline adviser Sergei Glaziev. Thus, Kudrin was getting nowhere. No Western journalist noted that fact at the time. Since December 2011, Ivanov always sat closest to Putin, showing that he was number two in the Kremlin, a fact which was also ignored.
A common view is that Putin is a full-fledged dictator, but that is a simplistic view. It matters which bodies are important and how they interact. At present, the Security Council is the real Politburo, the most senior body that meets regularly in a small closed circle chaired by Putin.
Stunningly, Putin does not control its composition. On April 5, he appointed his favorite former chief bodyguard General Viktor Zolotov, the newly-appointed commander of the new powerful National Guard, as a permanent member of the Security Council, but on April 11 another presidential decree demoted him to a mere member, of whom there are dozens, telling us that Putin was unable to defend him.
After Ivanov had been sacked as Chief of Staff, he stayed on the Security Council. Putin only removed the long-retired Interior Minister Rashid Nurgaliev from the Security Council and replaced him with his new Chief of Staff Anton Vaino. Thus, by means of Kremlinology—by studying organizations and appointments and not relying on any “inside” information—we could surmise that the Security Council could oust Putin.
Since April, Russia has seen a major rivalry between the country’s many security services through reorganizations and well-publicized arrests of high-level officials. One side is the FSB, the bulk of the old KGB, and the SVR (the foreign intelligence agency), while their opponents are the FSO (the Presidential Guard), the New National Guard, and Putin’s favorite Chechen President Ramzan Kadyrov. The Ministry of Defense may be an independent player.
Through his radical reorganizations, Putin has showed his preference for the FSO, the National Guard, and Kadyrov. But the opposite, FSB side dominates the 12-member Security Council: Ivanov, National Security Secretary Nikolay Patrushev, FSB Chair Alexander Bortnikov, and SVR chief Mikhail Fradkov. Interior Minister Vladimir Kolokoltsev must not like getting his best parts taken away, and Duma Speaker Sergey Naryshkin is identified with the other KGB generals.
Putin needs to change either the composition of the Security Council fast or make it unimportant, as Mikhail Gorbachev did with the Politburo. Otherwise Putin will sooner or later be ousted. As Talleyrand stated: “You can do anything you like with bayonets except to sit on them.” The Security Council should be front and center in current analysis of Russian politics, but analysts tend to ignore it.
What we ought to be ignoring, rather, is the official propaganda. On August 11, both Ivanov and Putin said that Ivanov had asked to leave after four years. Really? It was as obvious a lie as when Putin in September 2011 claimed that he and Medvedev had agreed four years earlier that Putin would return as President. The sacking of Ivanov came as a complete surprise to all, apart from us Kremlinologists, who saw this serious tension at the heart of the Kremlin, which became evident at the time of the murder of Boris Nemtsov at the Kremlin wall on February 27, 2015.
Similarly, we ought to ignore the more or less official Kremlin propagandists. They are only interesting as generators of Kremlin disinformation. Remember how the Brezhnev Kremlin warned about hardliners who would take over if he were ousted, or how nice a liberal reformer Yuriy Andropov was?
Kremlinology is a sound counterpoise to disinformation.
Anders Åslund is a senior fellow of the Atlantic Council.
Read the whole story

· · ·

Why the West Needs Kremlinology, Russia’s “Lost Decade,” and How Television Shapes Russian Consciousness

1 Share
In this week’s Western media highlights, Anders Åslund explains in the American Interest that the West needs to revive Kremlinology, a Soviet-era analytical approach to deciphering and understanding the opaque practices of Russian politics. Meanwhile, in the Russian media, Vladislav Inozemtsev argues that despite the popular view, Russia’s “lost decade” is not the current one, but was instead the first ten years under Putin’s rule. And sociologist Aleksei Levinson writes that state television does not control the Russian public mind; in fact, it’s the Russian people who choose self-censorship.
Next Page of Stories
Loading...
Page 8

US Military's Worst Nightmare: A War with Russia and China (at the Same Time) - The National Interest Online

1 Share

The National Interest Online

US Military's Worst Nightmare: A War with Russia and China (at the Same Time)
The National Interest Online
The United States discarded its oft-misunderstood “two war” doctrine, intended as a template for providing the means to fight two regional wars simultaneously, late last decade. Designed to deter North Korea from launching a war while the United States ...

and more »

May must explain Tory donor's links to Russia, says Labour MP - The Guardian

1 Share

The Guardian

May must explain Tory donor's links to Russia, says Labour MP
The Guardian
Rise Capital lists as partners three Russian banks that had sanctions imposed on them by the US and EU in 2014 in the wake of the Ukraine crisis. Sergei Romashov, the managing partner of Rise Capital, is understood to be close to Russia's president, ...

Is Kabardino-Balkaria The Caucasus Emirate’s Last Bastion?

1 Share
Over the past two years, the Caucasus Emirate (IK) proclaimed in late 2007 by then Chechen insurgency commander Doku Umarov has lost much of its manpower.

За отрицание аннексии - в "психушку" 

1 Share
From: SvobodaRadio
Duration: 04:42

В Крыму продолжаются акции крымских татар в защиту Ильми Умерова, которого преследуют за отрицание законности аннексии полуострова
Ссылка на источник - http://www.svoboda.org/a/27949351.html

Syria ceasefire draws closer after US-Russia talks

1 Share
Several issues resolved during John Kerry meeting with Sergei Lavrov, but parties fail to reach comprehensive agreement
A ceasefire in Syria is drawing closer after the US and Russia held diplomatic talks, but a final deal has yet to be reached, according to reports.
A number of issues blocking the restoration of a nationwide truce and wider aid deliveries were resolved at the 10-hour meeting in Geneva, but the US secretary of state, John Kerry, and his Russian counterpart, Sergei Lavrov, fell short of a comprehensive agreement. 
Continue reading...

Turkish Warplanes Hit Kurdish Positions In Northern Syria

1 Share
Turkish warplanes hit the positions of U.S.-backed Kurdish forces in northern Syria on August 27, days after Ankara launched a major operation to clear the region of Islamic State (IS) militants and Syrian Kurdish forces.

Next Page of Stories
Loading...
Page 9

Kyrgyz migrant workers killed in Moscow warehouse fire

1 Share
Officials say 16 victims of blaze at industrial unit in Russian capital thought to belong to printing company were from Kyrgyzstan
At least 16 migrant workers from Kyrgyzstan have died in a fire at a warehouse in Moscow, Russian authorities have said.
Firefighters arrived at 8am (5am BST) on Saturday at the scene, where a blaze had engulfed 200 sq metres of a warehouse in an industrial zone to the north of the Russian capital.
Continue reading...

Fire Kills at Least 16 in Moscow Printing Facility

1 Share
A fire in a warehouse at a Moscow printing facility killed at least 16 people on Saturday morning, an Emergencies Ministry official told Rossiya-24 TV station. "Sixteen bodies were found in a room, four injured were brought to hospitals in Moscow. The fire was completely put out by 9:53 am (6:53 UTC)," he said. The ministry said on its website that 12 people were rescued. The TV station said the people, who lived and worked at the depot, were mostly from former Soviet Union countries. The reason for the fire has not immediately been disclosed. Lax fire safety standards have often been blamed for such incidents in Russia.

Children Brutalized by IS Will Need Urgent Help, Experts Say

-

No comments:

Post a Comment